View Issue Details

IDProjectCategoryView StatusLast Update
0016553CentOS-8-OTHERpublic2020-03-24 12:09
Reportercvoltz 
PriorityurgentSeveritymajorReproducibilityN/A
Status newResolutionopen 
Product Version8.0.1905 
Target VersionFixed in Version 
Summary0016553: High availbility packages missing
DescriptionAll of the high availability (HA) packages are missing from the 8.0 release. The HA packages were provided in 7.0 release. The Red Hat 8.0 HA packages which are missing are:
  awscli
  booth
  booth-arbitrator
  booth-core
  booth-site
  booth-test
  clufter-bin
  clufter-cli
  clufter-common
  clufter-lib-ccs
  clufter-lib-general
  clufter-lib-pcs
  corosync
  corosync-qdevice
  corosync-qnetd
  corosynclib-devel
  fence-agents-aliyun
  fence-agents-aws
  fence-agents-azure-arm
  fence-agents-gce
  libknet1
  libknet1-compress-bzip2-plugin
  libknet1-compress-lz4-plugin
  libknet1-compress-lzma-plugin
  libknet1-compress-lzo2-plugin
  libknet1-compress-plugins-all
  libknet1-compress-zlib-plugin
  libknet1-crypto-nss-plugin
  libknet1-crypto-openssl-plugin
  libknet1-crypto-plugins-all
  libknet1-plugins-all
  pacemaker
  pacemaker-cli
  pacemaker-cts
  pacemaker-doc
  pacemaker-libs-devel
  pacemaker-nagios-plugins-metadata
  pacemaker-remote
  pcs
  pcs-snmp
  python3-azure-sdk
  python3-boto3
  python3-botocore
  python3-clufter
  python3-fasteners
  python3-gflags
  python3-google-api-client
  python3-httplib2
  python3-oauth2client
  python3-s3transfer
  python3-uritemplate
  resource-agents
  resource-agents-aliyun
  resource-agents-gcp

The key packages which are needed are:
  corosync
  corosynclib-devel
  pacemaker
  pacemaker-cli
  pacemaker-doc
  pacemaker-libs-devel
  pcs
  resource-agents
and any dependencies.
Additional InformationThe HA packages were available in CentOS 7.
Tagscentos 8

Activities

Balzache

Balzache

2019-10-10 04:36

reporter   ~0035422

Doh!
Just went looking for these myself!
Pacemaker where are you?!
Nooooooo!
cvoltz

cvoltz

2019-10-11 13:22

reporter   ~0035444

Source files from RH are available at ftp://ftp.redhat.com/redhat/rhel/rhel-8-beta/add-ons/ha/source/Packages/. For those who can't wait, binary RPMs are available at ftp://ftp.redhat.com/redhat/rhel/rhel-8-beta/add-ons/ha/x86_64/Packages/ or you can use the repo file at ftp://ftp.redhat.com/redhat/rhel/rhel-8-beta/rhel-8-beta.repo.
apevec

apevec

2019-10-16 14:57

reporter   ~0035504

+1 to include HA into c8 base, like it was in c7

RHEL8 pacemaker is exported to git.c.o c8 branch: https://git.centos.org/rpms/pacemaker/commits/c8
kdrhr

kdrhr

2019-10-21 13:23

reporter   ~0035538

Please add the packages from Resilient Storage Add-on (especially dlm) too.
ondrejhome

ondrejhome

2019-10-23 12:31

reporter   ~0035561

+1 for keeping the same approach as in CentOS7
digimer

digimer

2019-10-23 14:57

reporter   ~0035562

Another +1 for keeping the same approach as in CentOS 7.
hoonetorg

hoonetorg

2019-10-23 19:53

reporter   ~0035563

+1 to include HA into c8 base.

Just registered here, because I think it's important that CentOS and RHEL don't drift too much.

Not having HA in CentOS would be a big step in a direction I fear:
In a time CentOS is the perfect clone of RHEL, but it's only contains the stable packages from RHEL for an empty OS.
It's just an idling perfect clone of RHEL.
If you want to install some software on it, you must take the developer(-quality)-version of it from a SIG a 3rd Party repo or compile it yourself from the RHEL sources (and unbrand it)

I asked myself what will change when RedHat bought CentOS. I asked myself again what will change when IBM bought RedHat. Both times they said - nothing. Do I see signs here?
genchev

genchev

2019-10-24 15:42

reporter   ~0035573

+1 here as well. I hope it just an omission, and not the way to make CentOS into a lesser OS than RedHat.
akosprime

akosprime

2019-10-25 13:08

reporter   ~0035588

+1 to include HA into c8 base.
Xiol

Xiol

2019-10-30 16:01

reporter   ~0035609

+1 for including all of HA into C8 base, as was done for C7.

We were planning on using CentOS 8 as a base for a new product launch, but without Pacemaker we are unable to do so. I was very surprised to find it unavailable in the base repositories.
digimer

digimer

2019-10-30 20:26

reporter   ~0035612

To help CentOS users in the meantime, I have built the packages and added them to our repo[1]. Note that 'clufter'[2] is not include, as it relies on 'jing', which is not available in RHEL 8. As such, I removed 'python3-clufter' as a pcs dependency. The 'clufter' package principally provides an a way to convert older cman/rgmanager clusters to pacemaker, so this omission shouldn't effect most users.

1. https://www.alteeve.com/an-repo/el8/
2. https://lists.clusterlabs.org/pipermail/developers/2019-October/002233.html
digimer

digimer

2019-10-30 20:27

reporter   ~0035613

In addition; I should mention that I recompiled the src.rpms from RHEL 8, without any effort to maintain binary compatibility. These packages are entirely untested should be used for testing, not production.
digimer

digimer

2019-11-11 20:31

reporter   ~0035674

Is it possible to get an update on this ticket?
steevithak

steevithak

2019-11-18 16:04

reporter   ~0035705

How about DRBD too? Are RPMs for CentOS 8 available?
digimer

digimer

2019-11-18 18:57

reporter   ~0035706

DRBD doesn't ship with RHEL, so I would not expect them to be included in CentOS, either. They might be in EPEL 8 by now, not sure. If not, we have DRBD9 in our repo (https://www.alteeve.com/an-repo/el8/).
akosprime

akosprime

2019-11-20 15:11

reporter   ~0035716

+1 to finding out what the status of this is. My project isn't allowed to use rpm's from any source or repository, so we're not allowed to even checkout or test what digimer's done on his repository. So we're waiting for the official repository to release these.
akosprime

akosprime

2019-12-20 12:36

reporter   ~0035872

Is there ANY update on what's going on here? It's been almost 3 months since the bug was filed and I don't see a single comment, update, or statement from anyone responsible for the package(s) involved, or CentOS in general, only fellow users requesting that it be built, or asking for updates on it.
jdshewey

jdshewey

2020-01-07 19:57

reporter   ~0035959

+1 for keeping HA as part of base in c8 for me and my company as well.
HP_InkJet

HP_InkJet

2020-01-07 20:12

reporter   ~0035960

Me and my colleagues as well think that HA packages should be included in the base repo. +1
apevec

apevec

2020-01-07 20:44

reporter   ~0035962

pacemaker is coming in 8.1, preview is in CR repo http://mirror.centos.org/centos/8/cr/x86_64/os/Packages/
digimer

digimer

2020-01-07 20:57

reporter   ~0035964

Are all the associated HA packages coming as well? I don't see 'pcs' or a few others.
amoralej

amoralej

2020-01-08 10:25

reporter   ~0035967

Note that some libraries which are pacemaker anc corosyn subpackages are included in CentOS baseOS. That was in 8.0 and that's what is in CR, but the actual packages in HA repos are still missing.
amoralej

amoralej

2020-01-08 10:36

reporter   ~0035968

i see some 8.1 builds in mbox https://koji.mbox.centos.org/koji/buildinfo?buildID=5940 but not shipped in CR, will they be available in 8.1 GA?
akosprime

akosprime

2020-01-27 10:36

reporter   ~0036130

I don't see 'pcs', 'pacemaker', 'pacemaker-cli', 'corosync', 'resource-agents' packages available. Of pacemaker packages I only see 'pacemaker-cluster-libs', 'pacemaker-libs', and 'pacemaker-schemas'. Of corosync I only see 'corosynclib' and 'corosync-vqsim'. As amoralej mentioned though I do see those packages in the koji mbox, but not in CR, or 8.1 repos.

On a 7.x system required packages for 'pcs' that also appear to be missing are: 'clufter-common', 'clufter-bin', and 'python-clufter'; I don't know if these are still prereq's for 'pcs' under 8.x or not.
amoralej

amoralej

2020-01-27 10:39

reporter   ~0036131

Hi,

You need to enable "HighAvailability" repository in CentOS8 and you'll find all HA packages there since 8.1.
akosprime

akosprime

2020-01-27 10:56

reporter   ~0036132

AH! Thank you! I feel like an idiot, but at least things are there, so I'll take a public shaming for that! :-)
kdrhr

kdrhr

2020-02-04 10:41

reporter   ~0036194

I confirm the HA packages are in the 8.1 HA repo.

However the package dlm from resilient storage is still missing. It's not even in Koji :(.
tizo

tizo

2020-02-17 14:06

reporter   ~0036298

Hello there,

Does anyone know another way of installing dlm package in the meantime?.

Thanks very much.

Just in case, there is a bug report for the lack of this package: https://bugs.centos.org/view.php?id=16939
kdrhr

kdrhr

2020-02-17 14:43

reporter   ~0036299

dlm and dlm-lib build quite fine from the source at https://git.centos.org/rpms/dlm/tree/9ac4d39aaee57cc2b28b0851e4c764c61a6d58b8

There are a few packages you have to install for the build process though. Also from PowerTools repo if I remember correctly.
jdshewey

jdshewey

2020-03-06 17:25

reporter   ~0036472

There is a separate bug open for the missing dlm package: https://bugs.centos.org/view.php?id=16939
kdrhr

kdrhr

2020-03-09 07:42

reporter   ~0036481

All of the packages from description have been added to the repositories.

Missing dlm has it's own bug report.

This issue is resolved and can be CLOSED.
tjyang

tjyang

2020-03-21 11:43

reporter   ~0036545

I haven't really deploy centOS 8 cluster using pacemaker. But following output looks pacemaker pkgs are ported.

[root@centos8t01 ~]# cat /etc/redhat-release
CentOS Linux release 8.1.1911 (Core)
[root@centos8t01 ~]# dnf config-manager --set-enabled HighAvailability
[root@centos8t01 ~]# dnf info corosync.x86_64 pacemaker
CentOS-8 - HA 18 kB/s | 3.8 kB 00:00
Available Packages
Name : corosync
Version : 3.0.2
Release : 3.el8_1.1
Architecture : x86_64
Size : 261 k
Source : corosync-3.0.2-3.el8_1.1.src.rpm
Repository : HighAvailability
Summary : The Corosync Cluster Engine and Application Programming
             : Interfaces
URL : http://corosync.github.io/corosync/
License : BSD
Description : This package contains the Corosync Cluster Engine Executive,
             : several default APIs and libraries, default configuration files,
             : and an init script.

Name : pacemaker
Version : 2.0.2
Release : 3.el8_1.2
Architecture : x86_64
Size : 429 k
Source : pacemaker-2.0.2-3.el8_1.2.src.rpm
Repository : HighAvailability
Summary : Scalable High-Availability cluster resource manager
URL : http://www.clusterlabs.org
License : GPLv2+ and LGPLv2+
Description : Pacemaker is an advanced, scalable High-Availability cluster
             : resource manager.
             :
             : It supports more than 16 node clusters with significant
             : capabilities for managing resources and dependencies.
             :
             : It will run scripts at initialization, when machines go up or
             : down, when related resources fail and can be configured to
             : periodically check resource health.
             :
             : Available rpmbuild rebuild options:
             : --with(out) : coverage doc stonithd hardening pre_release
             : profiling

[root@centos8t01 ~]#

Issue History

Date Modified Username Field Change
2019-10-07 17:40 cvoltz New Issue
2019-10-07 17:40 cvoltz Tag Attached: centos 8
2019-10-10 04:36 Balzache Note Added: 0035422
2019-10-11 13:22 cvoltz Note Added: 0035444
2019-10-16 14:57 apevec Note Added: 0035504
2019-10-21 13:23 kdrhr Note Added: 0035538
2019-10-23 12:31 ondrejhome Note Added: 0035561
2019-10-23 14:57 digimer Note Added: 0035562
2019-10-23 19:53 hoonetorg Note Added: 0035563
2019-10-24 15:42 genchev Note Added: 0035573
2019-10-25 13:08 akosprime Note Added: 0035588
2019-10-30 16:01 Xiol Note Added: 0035609
2019-10-30 20:26 digimer Note Added: 0035612
2019-10-30 20:27 digimer Note Added: 0035613
2019-11-11 20:31 digimer Note Added: 0035674
2019-11-18 16:04 steevithak Note Added: 0035705
2019-11-18 18:57 digimer Note Added: 0035706
2019-11-20 15:11 akosprime Note Added: 0035716
2019-12-20 12:36 akosprime Note Added: 0035872
2020-01-07 19:57 jdshewey Note Added: 0035959
2020-01-07 20:12 HP_InkJet Note Added: 0035960
2020-01-07 20:44 apevec Note Added: 0035962
2020-01-07 20:57 digimer Note Added: 0035964
2020-01-08 10:25 amoralej Note Added: 0035967
2020-01-08 10:36 amoralej Note Added: 0035968
2020-01-27 10:36 akosprime Note Added: 0036130
2020-01-27 10:39 amoralej Note Added: 0036131
2020-01-27 10:56 akosprime Note Added: 0036132
2020-02-04 10:41 kdrhr Note Added: 0036194
2020-02-17 14:06 tizo Note Added: 0036298
2020-02-17 14:43 kdrhr Note Added: 0036299
2020-03-06 17:25 jdshewey Note Added: 0036472
2020-03-09 07:42 kdrhr Note Added: 0036481
2020-03-21 11:43 tjyang Note Added: 0036545